High Technology Comes To The Rescue In Land Of Stampedes

Sometimes a good idea hiding in plain sight comes at last to the fore and begins to receive due attention. Home Minister Amit Shah, exasperated no doubt at the endless deaths and injuries that is giving India a bad name for callousness, has come up with a plan.

It applies to a host of situations, though he specifically mentioned temples. It could be used at political rallies, weddings, funerals, processions, railway stations, hordes going to hill stations, forts, any other large moving or static gathering. It applies also to ecologically sensitive areas in the mountains, rivers, lakes, animal sanctuaries, other tourist spots.

This is by way of a first national SOP (standard operating procedure) for crowd control and will prevent needless deaths and injuries if strictly implemented.

It will become the first design and template for excuse-proof structured crowd management. Of course, a lot of work needs to be done on it, because, particularly for ancient temples and temple towns, and traditional pilgrimages and melas. It applies to the crowds going to the Char Dhams in Uttarakhand, the Jagannath Rath Yatra in Puri, The Sabarimala in the South, Vaishno Devi and Amarnath in J&K. Huge congregations of the old and infirm such as at the Ganga Sagar in West Bengal, men women, children, sadhus, foreigners at the gargantuan Kumbh Melas held every four years, culminating in the Mahakumbh at Prayagraj. It is clear the SOP needs to be elaborate because one size does not fit all. It could be worked into a law by parliament and the state legislatures so that breaches and flouting of it can be punished without constituting fact finding committees after each disaster.

Ingress by bus, train, aircraft, on foot, and departure by similar means, needs looking at, inclusive of traffic routing, parking and controlled arrivals and departure.

A beginning on this was made at the last Maha Kumbh Mela which, though it saw a couple of stampedes, was by far the best managed gathering at the Prayagraj Sangam ever. It was also the greatest such gathering ever held on earth.Full marks for that goes not only to the Centre but also the Yogi Adityanath government in Uttar Pradesh. And yet people broke through police barriers in their indiscipline and trampled others underfoot. Statistically it may not have been much but the human tragedy in this and all other such incidents cannot be wished away.

Use of  new tools such as AI for crowd management,  and drones to oversee the crowd movements forms part of it, along with real time communication between administration, police and para military forces deployed to regulate and guide crowds. Lighting, medical facilities, epidemic control, water, toilets, accommodation, food, all need to be adequate to ample.

Political interference, with the authorities and others on high manipulations including out of turn VIP access, that disrupts security must be strictly avoided. These do untold damage to the common man even if an SOP is in place because it overrides instructions. The SOP could well restrict the VIP appearances to Video conferencing to avoid the special security needs of such people.

The need felt for an SOP has come not a moment to soon in a country teeming with over 1.4 billion people. Many of the people routinely killed in stampedes are the weak, the elderly, women and children.

Of course, in addition to restricting the numbers admitted to a crowded venue, including the routes leading to it, attention needs to be paid to entry points/ internal pathways and routing, seating, and separate exits so that they do not make for classic choke points. 

Here too, like roads that are made one ways to let one side out before the other is let in, or boarding procedures at aircraft, crowd management is a must. 

Compensation paid to the families of the dead and injured after yet another disaster runs a poor second to prevention. So does trying to pinpoint blame, always inconclusive, after the fact.

Mere breach of permissions and flouting of stated rules, which happens with sickening regularity both by the organisers and the people, can be anticipated and prevented.

Temple access is often through ancient and crowded areas and as in Varanasi at the Kashi Vishwanath temple and also at Ujjain modern avenues may have to be rebuilt by demolishing old buildings and pathways. This has been done extensively also at Ayodhya, where a lot of infrastructure has also been recently created by way of hotels, the airport, a new and renovated railway station, roads. Likewise at Varanasi. Similar works are being carried out at Mathura by means of a special corridor. Facilities at Katra at the start of the Vasno Devi yatra is another case in point. Roads to the Char Dhams are largely renovated and expanded. Ropeways are being put in.

In other words, the SOP  must include a much broader swathe of works, extending much beyond the local area. All of it, now well underway in terms of modernisation of infrastructure contributes to the convenience and safety called for.

In India it might have been long assumed that human life is cheap. It is perhaps  only now being regarded as valuable because for decades, if not centuries,  very little regard was paid to those who were killed by flood, famine, pestilence, marauders, riots, let alone stampedes.

But no country that is on its way to shortly becoming the third largest economy in the world can afford to treat its citizens with such scant respect. Indians may be numerous, and India may have the largest population in the world, but it is this very fact that gives us an enormous and young workforce that powers us ahead. Education, civic sense, medical facilities all come into the mix to lift ourselves out of the stampede culture we have had to endure for far too long. Home Minister Amit Shah must be commended for his sterling initiative and the administration must implement his SOP with diligence and alacrity.

(995 words)

October 3^rd, 2025

For: Firstpost/News18.com

Gautam Mukherjee